Cargo Insurance – To Insure or Not to Insure?
- Requirement: Cargo interests who elect not to insure their shipments are, in effect, gambling with their financial exposure. As the saying goes, the house always wins. While cargo interests may initially enjoy modest savings by avoiding insurance premiums and experiencing no losses, a single major casualty could wipe out years of accumulated savings and, in extreme cases, threaten the very survival of their business. The requirement of whether the cargo is insured or not is generally in the sale contract and which will detail as to whether the responsibility lies with the seller or buyer of the cargo1.
- Scope of Cargo Insurance and the Value of Insurers:
- Cargo insurance is generally either arranged on an All Risks basis under the Institute Cargo Clauses (A) 2009, or on a more restricted basis under the Institute Cargo Clauses (B) or (C) 2009. Depending on the applicable terms, conditions and exclusions, the cargo cover provides protection against physical loss of or damage to cargo, together with certain associated exposures, including General Average, Salvage and Sue and Labour expenses2.
- The fundamental purpose of cargo insurance is to protect the insured against the uncertainties and risks inherent in maritime transportation. It is therefore essential that the cover is appropriate to the exposures involved and placed with a reputable insurer capable of responding promptly and effectively to claims.
- Equally important is the insurer’s ability to assist in managing claims, preserving evidence, coordinating surveys and pursuing recoveries against responsible parties. This is a significant, yet often overlooked, benefit of cargo insurance, as insurers generally possess the expertise, resources and international networks that individual cargo interests may not have readily available to pursue recovery against the errant Bailor/Carrier.
- Cover:
- Cargo insurance cover provided is generally on a warehouse-to-warehouse basis, subject to the applicable transit provisions and the insured having the requisite insurable interest at the time of loss.
- Marine insurance is a specialised field, and the mere existence of an insurance policy does not necessarily mean that all relevant exposures are adequately addressed. Participants in maritime trade would therefore be well advised to engage suitably qualified professionals to undertake a comprehensive risk-mapping exercise, assess the available insurance arrangements and identify cover that best meets their commercial and operational requirements.
- Misdeclaration and Risk Prevention:
- Casualties arising from the misdeclaration of cargo present significant challenges to the maritime industry. Where such misdeclaration is deliberate or fraudulent, the party responsible should not assume that its insurance arrangements will respond, particularly where the loss arises from its own unlawful or wilful misconduct.
- Similarly, Carriers should not be under the mistaken apprehension that the cargo insurance or for that matter any of the downward parties (intermediary carriers) would respond to any mis-declaration or reckless behaviour of the Insured given that these insurance covers are meant more for the First Party rather than Third Parties. Accordingly, Prevention is arguably more important than say the cargo being insured. Carriers should therefore implement robust customer due diligence, cargo verification and risk-management procedures to minimise the likelihood of accepting misdeclared or dangerous cargo.
- Carriers and for that matter business partners involved in the sale and purchase of cargo should know their counterparts, the nature of their businesses, track records and the cargoes being shipped. The objective should be to establish relationships with credible, responsible cargo interests and counterparties rather than exposing vessels and other stakeholders to unnecessary risks arising from short-term commercial considerations.
- Pursuit of Overlying Contractual Parties:
- One of the fallacies which cargo interest generally have is that they would have a right to pursue their overlying contractual party (which may be a Freight Forwarder (“FF”) or the Carrier) for any and all losses arising during the voyage. The fact is that FF or Carrier contract on terms which entitle them to exclude liability in certain circumstances (not an actionable fault) and limit liability when they are not entitled to exclude liability. We take each in turn:
- FF may act purely as agent or as a contractual party i.e. issuing their Bills of Lading (“B/L”) and in which case, they act as Carriers and which will be considered as below. While in some Civil Law countries, FF’s may have concurrent liabilities akin to Carriers as provided in their local legislations, the law, at least in common law countries, requires that in order to pursue for recovery, there must be evidence of fault or negligence on the part of the FF. If the loss occurs without any causative negligence of the FF3, the FF have a complete defence to any and all claims which may be raised by the cargo interests.
- Carrier’s: A Carrier would invariably contract on terms (as seen in the terms and conditions of a B/L) and which would, subject to proper notice and incorporation, entitle them to the provisions of the contract and which would include both exclusions and limitations of liability. Additionally, statutory defences such as the Hague Visby Rules as incorporated in the country of loading or where the Bill of Lading is issued, may be available such that the Carrier would be entitled to exclude and/or limit liability as provided in law. The fact is that the Carriers have a number of defences entitling them to exclude liability and if they are unable to do so, they are entitled to limit liability to sums which may be a fraction of the cargo lost or damaged. This being the case, an uninsured cargo owner may find that the recovery, even if successful, is not of enough succour.
- Even if cargo interests would have a valid right to pursue, given the short limitation period (1 year time bar) and the costs for pursuit vis-à-vis the amounts involved, it may not make commercial sense to pursue. This being the case, invariably for small claims4, the cargo interests would have to bear the losses by themselves unless they have an appropriate cargo insurance and in which case, once the cargo interests have been paid their claim by their cargo insurers, the subrogated cargo insurers can consider as to whether they wish to pursue further with the recovery or not.
- One of the fallacies which cargo interest generally have is that they would have a right to pursue their overlying contractual party (which may be a Freight Forwarder (“FF”) or the Carrier) for any and all losses arising during the voyage. The fact is that FF or Carrier contract on terms which entitle them to exclude liability in certain circumstances (not an actionable fault) and limit liability when they are not entitled to exclude liability. We take each in turn:
- NVOCCs and Vessel/Feeder Operators – A Question of Equity
- In recent years, Vessel and Feeder Operators have increasingly required NVOCCs to maintain substantial third-party liability insurance, sometimes with minimum limits of USD 5 million per incident or occurrence. While appropriate liability insurance is undoubtedly important, imposing such limits indiscriminately, without regard to the nature, scale and actual risk exposure of the NVOCC’s operations, may be disproportionate.
- Interestingly, there appears to be considerably less emphasis on reciprocal minimum insurance requirements for Vessel and Feeder Operators themselves, including say GA absorption clauses / small GA clauses. It is our view that having requirements for Vessel and Feeder Operators to maintain appropriate Small General Average cover, with limits equivalent to at least 10% of the vessel’s hull value, would help reduce the need to declare General Average in less significant casualties, depending on the scope and terms of such cover.
- To Insure or Not to Insure – Is the Risk Worth Taking?
- The fundamental question is whether the potential savings from foregoing insurance justify the financial exposure. Unless an entity has sufficient financial resources and an appropriately structured fund to self-insure against substantial losses, the prudent course would be to obtain cargo insurance, particularly when premiums are relatively modest and arranging cover is generally straightforward.
- Ultimately, the cost of insurance should be weighed against the potentially devastating consequences of an uninsured loss. Cargo interests who choose to remain uninsured are, in effect, playing roulette with their financial future. While they may enjoy short-term savings, a single major casualty could prove catastrophic. By then, the familiar refrain of “I told you so” would offer little consolation.
1. Sale contract and which may, amongst others, provide for sale on CIF/CIP, C&F/CPT or FOB/FCA.
2. For details of the cover, see guide published by CASRAI.
3. See article on “The liability of Freight Forwarders” by Ms Konstadina Kottoros, Lotus Shipping & Clearing LLC, Dubai, published in Lloyd’s Shipping & Trade Law on 26th Aug 2009.
4. What are small claims is a question of fact and would depend on the jurisdiction where the claim is being pursued or defended. We believe that it would not be commercially sensible to pursue a claim for a sum of say USD 50,000 in jurisdictions such as Singapore or UK. However, if the dispute resolution clause provides for disputes to be resolved by arbitration and given that there are expedited procedures and capped costs in arbitral rules of SCMA, LMAA and HKMAG, pursuit can indeed be initiated for lower sums – say USD 20,000 or so.





